The Catholic Thing
Reading the Church Fathers and Doctors Print E-mail
By Randall Smith   
Sunday, 13 June 2010

In Culture and Anarchy, Matthew Arnold famously spoke of the importance of acquainting oneself with “the best that has been thought and said in the world.” In the early 1900s, Harvard President Charles W. Eliot gushed about the classics of Western literature – a group of texts that could, he indicated, fit on a three-foot shelf. A publisher challenged Eliot, and he compiled a fifty-one-volume anthology called “The Harvard Classics.” But the original “three-foot shelf” had become (as the popular name implied): “Dr. Eliot’s Five-Foot Shelf.” In the 1920s and 30s, Prof. John Erskine of Columbia University helped spark a conversation among prominent American educators about returning our higher education system to its roots in the so-called “Great Books of Western Civilization.” Erskine and his contemporaries – men such as Robert Hutchins, Mortimer Adler, Stringfellow Barr, and Alexander Meiklejohn – founded or inspired a host of Great Books programs. Certainly much of their effort was admirable, and helped counteract the tendency toward pragmatism and increasing specialization in American higher education.

Yet, if you examine “Great Books” list, you’ll notice something missing. Confucius is there, the Buddha too, as are selections from the Koran and the Bhagavad-Gita (and these in lists from 1909!). But look a little closer, and you’ll find that, between the death of Ovid in 18 AD and Thomas Aquinas’ birth in 1225, only the New Testament and St. Augustine make the list. It’s as though almost nothing of intellectual importance emerged in Europe from the end of the Roman Empire until the beginning of the Renaissance, except for the work of two men whose genius is undeniable even to such “enlightened” list-makers: Augustine and Aquinas. What’s missing, in other words, are nearly all the early Church Fathers and Doctors: St. Ambrose, St. Jerome, and St. Gregory the Great, St. Basil the Great, St. John Chrysostom, St. Gregory of Nazianzen, and St. Athanasius. You’ll look in vain for any of the other early “doctors of the Church” either (other than Aquinas): no Leo the Great, no John Damascene, no Anselm, Bernard of Clairvaux, Bonaventure, Catherine of Siena, or John of the Cross. Nothing. Zero. Zilch. Nada.

But if our goal is to read “the best that has been thought and said in the world,” we simply mustn’t leave them out. For Catholics, the Fathers and Doctors of the Church are our Great Books. They should be for Catholics what reading the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Federalist Papers should be for American citizens: indispensable guides to our founding principles.

But there’s more. It’s not merely that works such as Athanasius’ On the Incarnation and The Life of Anthony are infinitely more intelligent (and indeed more influential) than anything written by, say, Marcus Aurelius (a dedicated and pious Roman, yes, but his Meditations are pretty thin gruel). The Fathers and Doctors are also truer. They were often better philosophers than their contemporaries, with a better grasp of the fundamental realities: human nature, the nature of society, the world, and God. Nearly the only people still interested in someone like the pagan philosopher Plotinus are those who feel they need to be familiar with his thought in order to better understand Christian writers like Origen, Basil, Gregory, and Augustine. In other words, only Christians still read pagan philosophers such as Plotinus with real interest.

In Joseph Ratzinger’s 1969 book Introduction to Christianity, the future pope asked: “Wherein, then, lies the permanent value, the indispensability, of the Fathers of the Church?” He gave four reasons. First, the canon of Scripture can be traced back to them. It is through their efforts that those books we call the “New Testament” were chosen from among a multitude of other available literary texts. Second, the Church Fathers were responsible for giving birth to the fundamental symbola (the creeds and baptismal oaths) of all Christendom. Third, the Fathers helped to create the fundamental forms of the Christian liturgical service. And finally, by constructing the original marriage between Christian revelation and Greek philosophy, the Fathers set forth a model for later generations of the necessary dialogue between faith and reason.

The Fathers “acknowledged their rational responsibility for the faith,” announces Ratzinger, “and thus created theology as we understand it today.” “This was the precondition for the survival of Christendom in the West,” he says, as it is also the “precondition for the survival of the Christian way of life today and tomorrow.”

In a 1990 instruction, the Congregation for Catholic Education stated that, “theological reflection has always been clearly aware that there is something in the fathers which is unique, irreplaceable, and perennially valid, as relevant as ever.” And as Pope John Paul II has said: “The Church still lives today by the life received from her fathers, and on the foundation erected by her first constructors she is still being built today in the joy and sorrow of her journeying and daily toil.”

Try looking into them. You will find heights of philosophical speculation that many on the standard list of “Greats,” with their relatively limited scope, never reach. And you will plumb depths of understanding of the human condition – both of the infinite good of which man is capable, having been made in the image of God, as well as the depths of evil into which his soul can tragically fall – of which only true pastors of the human soul are fully aware. These are the kind of wise guides for life's journey so desperately needed today – a generation, as Walker Percy once described as, “lost in the cosmos.”

Randall Smith, a new contributor, is associate professor of theology at the University of St. Thomas, Houston.
(c) 2010 The Catholic Thing. All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info at thecatholicthing dot org

The Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (8)Add Comment
written by Fr. Paul J. Keller, O.P., June 14, 2010
Great insight, Randy!
Verbum caro factum est
written by Willie, June 14, 2010
Very good piece! The origins of Christian theology and Latin mysticism can be traced back to the meshing of Greek philosophy and the thinking of the early Fathers. An understanding of Western civilization could not be complete without reading the Church Fathers. Contemporary academic curricula are robbing us of a true historical perspective. The early Fathers realized that the Greek gods and the Christian God had become One. Perhaps the stage was set by Plato, Plotinus, Pythagoras and others for a true understanding of Christian theology and spirituality.
written by Ted, June 14, 2010
Might there be a Dr. Smith’s Five-Foot Shelf?
Bibliographical List?
written by JKealey, June 14, 2010
Is it possible to create a printable list of "must-reads" of this field? Or perhaps an introductory text to the writings of the Church Fathers?
written by Bill W, June 14, 2010
Thanks for the challenge, now where would be the best place to start... Hendrickson Publishers- The Fathers Of The Church; Catholic University of America Press- The Fathers of the Church Series; or Paulist Press- Ancient Christian Writers?
Partial Answer to Recommendations
written by AHR, June 14, 2010
I just finished reading The Greek Fathers by Adrian Fortesque. I highly recommend it as a good introduction to the Fathers. The author was an accomplished Latin priest who admired and understood the importance of the Eastern-Church. Each chapter includes recommendations for further reading.
Some Recommendations
written by Randall Smith, June 15, 2010
There is, in fact, already a "five-foot shelf" of books for the Fathers of the Early Church. There are two series: one is the Ante-Nicene Fathers; the other is the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers. Both series are edited by Alexander Roberts et al. The series is a wonderful resource, but can be a bit overwhelming. The translations are also delightful if you like the Nineteenth Century style of English prose.

For those who want something smaller, I am a big fan of the volumes in the "Library of Christian Classics" series, under the general editorship of John Baillie and published by Westminster Press. The volume entitled "Early Christian Fathers," edited by Cyril C. Richardson, is a wonderful introduction to the Apostolic Fathers of the First and Second Centuries. Then there's the volume on "The Christology of the Later Fathers," edited by E. R. Hardy, which contains wonderful texts by Athanasius, Basil, Gregory of Nazianzen, and Gregory of Nyssa. There's also a volume on "Early Latin Theology" and "Augustine: Later Works."

For those just starting out, I suggest reading Augustine's "Confessions" (available in so many translations, each of which has fans, that it would be ridiculous for me to list one). There's also the wonderful translation of Athanasius's "On the Incarnation" with an introduction by C. S. Lewis, which is highly worthwhile. And a lovely new little translation of Gregory of Nyssa's "Life of Moses" available through Harper Collins Spiritual Classics.

Another possibility is simply to Google "Fathers and Doctors of the Church," write down some names, and then go on-line to search for any books by any of those authors. That would also work.

The deposits of silver and gold are so vast that there are innumerable ways of mining them. Some you can pick up right on the surface. Others you'll need to dig down a bit. But once you've tapped into that rich vein, you'll want to keep coming back from whatever direction you can get at it.
And don't forget
written by Brad Miner, June 17, 2010
Benedict XVI has a two-volumne guide: The Fathers. You may order it at the TCT store at Amazon (accessible by clicking on any of the book jackets on the right side of this page.)

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters