The Catholic Thing
Religiously Unmusical - and Musical Print E-mail
By Robert Royal   
Sunday, 27 June 2010

The Curé of Ars, who knew something on the subject, once said, “Leave a parish without a priest for twenty years, and they will begin to worship beasts.” The good curé did not live to see our even more radical variants: ecological religions where people worship vegetation and even minerals. But something similar might be said about the effect of bad or incomplete priests or of a Church failing to evangelize fully. Not only does the loss of true religion inevitably lead back to false religions like paganism, as the Bible clearly attests, it leads to taking what is false or only partly true for Truth. 

The Catholic tradition calls that heresy, in the old and true sense of the word: selecting out and focusing exclusively on a part and presenting it as if it were the whole. This explains a lot about modern unbelief, especially when culture loses touch with religious reality and elites start to become what Max Weber, the sociologist of religion, called “religiously unmusical.” That’s a great way to put it. It makes clear that many people who think they have escaped religious narrowness and naivete for secular freedom and sophistication, are in fact suffering from a different naivete and a kind of tone deafness to a whole range of the beautiful and the true.

I was in Paris this week at a conference on secularization organized by a group I’ve mentioned before: the Lumen Christi Institute at the University of Chicago, which is simply the world’s best Catholic study center on a secular campus. The setting itself was significant. About ten years ago, then Archbishop of Paris Cardinal Jean Lustiger decided to restore the Collège des Bernardins, the medieval Bernardine college, as a center to promote vigorous Catholic engagement with the culture. It was a gutsy move in France, which in many respects is the flagship nation of modern secularization. But the college has reinvigorated something far from dead, and research programs in bioethics, courses on Catholic issues, and lectures and art exhibits provide a high-level Catholic presence in French culture.

Our conference centered around a book, A Secular Age, by the Canadian Catholic philosopher, Charles Taylor, a world renowned figure who won the 2007 Templeton Prize for Religion. Taylor was present and responded to presentations by a select group of scholars from France, America, England, Germany, and Poland. We all agreed that the basic model once accepted in scholarly circles – that modernization simply leads to secularization – is not only false: there are plenty of signs that something more interesting is going on, especially in the last decade or so, though it’s hard to describe precisely and can’t be used to make firm predictions.

Around the world, there is religious ferment, and not only among Muslims and fundamentalists, which helps explain why the Richard Dawkins and his ilk are in such a nasty panic. Taylor expressed frustration that there are so many seekers, especially young people, and yet cultural forces have blocked them from realizing that the Church has great riches for those who search – indeed, that the Church itself seeks God more zealously than anyone.

Many odd facts cropped up this week. For instance, a Jesuit living in Sweden – ground zero for the secular neutron bomb – described religion there as quite weak. And no wonder. The state is quite strong in shocking ways. Children at eighteen receive a state allowance, not for higher education, but to become independent of parents. On the surface, this seems mad, but it has a purpose. The state wants to make people into radically autonomous individuals who can be dealt with separately, with as little allegiance to traditional groupings like families as possible. Clearly, the “independence” this introduces conceals the fact that it begins a long life of dependence – on the state – for many things.

Swedish policies have, perhaps unintentionally, kept birth rates rather high compared with the rest of Europe. But this has come at the cost of the state replacing husbands with handouts. Swedish women continue to have children, but over half are born out of wedlock and only 60 percent of women ever marry (the U.S. figure, which has also declined, is 85 percent). This does not bode well for Sweden or for family and church.

But contrary to what many think, Europe is the exception in the flight from religious traditions. And even there, strong contrary currents flow. Paris itself, just had its priestly ordinations this weekend. Though there were only nine – down a lot from the past – 10,000 people attended the ceremonies. These young men come almost exclusively from traditional parishes and movements, and they make the unusual choice of vocation in order to make a difference. We know that secularism is more prominent now than in the past, but even in France those who are religious are perhaps more strongly so than in quite a while.

A friend who has lived many years in Paris took me to a packed Mass at the Church of San Gervais where the Fraternities of Jerusalem, groups of men and women religious and lay people who work half time in the world and pray half time in the church, has one of the most hauntingly beautiful liturgies I’ve ever seen. They pay attention to every detail, but especially music. And that attentive spirit draws number of participants and vocations. Founded in 1975 by a genius of a priest, Pierre-Marie Delfieux, there are now offshoot foundations in Rome, Florence, Vezelay. Strasbourg, Mont St. Michel, Brussels, Montreal, Cologne, Warsaw, and Magdala (Israel) among other initiatives.

You’ve probably never heard of them, but maybe it’s time that some of us begin to make them and similar phenomena better known. Because if our public culture is religiously unmusical, private groups like this are bringing back the most musical and attractive spirituality into a modern world that desperately wants to hear it.

Robert Royal is editor-in-chief of The Catholic Thing, and president of the Faith & Reason Institute in WashingtonD.C. His most recent book is The God That Did Not Fail: How Religion Built and Sustains the West.

©2010 The Catholic Thing. All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info at thecatholicthing dot org

The Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (8)Add Comment
cure of ars
written by agustinus purnama, June 28, 2010
I have learned that Korea was at one time left without the hierarchy for more than a century and yet Catholic life has kept flourishing.
No religion or false religion?
written by Giuseppe, June 28, 2010
Mr. Royal writes, "Around the world, there is religious ferment, and not only among Muslims and fundamentalists, which helps explain why the Richard Dawkins and his ilk are in such a nasty panic."

A question that arises is whether it's better to believe in no God, as Richard Dawkins does (other than himself), or to believe in a false God, as the Islamists do. Who is more dangerous, Mr. Dawkins, who, along with countless other non-believers, still have an opportunity to find their way to the true God of Christianity, or the thousands of radical Muslim jihadists who blow themselves up and others and commit all sorts of violence to attain their "paradise"?

I submit that as noxous as Richard Dawkins and his ilk may seem to the Church, he is relatively harmless and remains open to conversion to the faith, unlike those who follow a false religion zealously and have closed their minds to the truth.
written by Joe, June 28, 2010
Good points well made. Dawkins et al have recently stepped up their attacks in what certainly appears to be a kind of panic. Any reasonable person looking around at the popular "culture" (see Real Housewives of New Jersey if a refresher is required) must feel queasy. Secular statists in their triumphalism at the "end of history" have taken us perilously close to the edge of ... something nasty covered in mist for now. Most people suspect, even if they do not articulate it, that when the mist burns away we will all be face to face with something very unpleasant indeed.
Fraternities of Jerusalem
written by CatholicTide, June 28, 2010
Fraternities of Jerusalem sounds very interesting. Do you know if they have a presence in the US? I couldn't find anything on their website.
written by Naomi, June 28, 2010
Wonderful, Mr. Royal..absolutely wonderful essay. I hate to admit it, but I would rather read this website and publications like First Things, Catholic World Report, Inside the Vatican, Homiletic and Pastoral Review and Touchstone..or any one of the above,than listen to one year of sermons from the pulpit. I hate to say it, but it is true. One wonders what our clergy are reading these days. You can only give what you've got !!!
written by Lee Gilbert, June 28, 2010
"You’ve probably never heard of them, but maybe it’s time that some of us begin to make them and similar phenomena better known."

Alright, here you go. Have you heard of the Carmelites of Valparaiso, NE? Their Mass and all offices are in Latin, but nevertheless they have had many young women enter their convent recently to the point that they've had to make a new foundation in PA...and are preparing to make another.

Then there is the 150 member Latin Mass community at St. Birgitta's in Portland, OR that has already contributed two nun to Valparaiso, with another two in the wings, and a third going to a cloistered Dominican order in LA. Two young men from the parish are studying for the priesthood, one with the Carmelites of Wyoming, another is a deacon with the Priestly Society of St. Peter. Other young people of the parish are expressing interest in religious life.

There is a message here someplace for bishops and vocation directors. There is not the least doubt that young people want authenticity. Not wearing a habit, having a labyrinth, and and flaunting a spirituality of resentment toward the Magisterium is institutional suicide. To the religiously inclined young people of today it says, "We are as flakey as can be, and won't be around long. If you want to be part of a death watch, join us." When are these nuns going to wake up? It's tragic, really.

Nevertheless, the Lord is at work and the traditional orders are flourishing.

Well, the positive news is that relgious life is flourishing
boysville of michigan
written by bonehead, June 28, 2010
where have you gone to observe spiritual manifestations?

4 example .. when i went to Medjugorje .. i observed the VM spirit appearing 2 the visionaries.. and other manifestations.. that can be now observed on U-tube
In Re Korea
written by Thomas C. Coleman, Jr., June 28, 2010
Dear Augustinus: To clarify on Korea, Koreans who were baptized by Jesuits in China returned to Korea in 1783 and preached and baptized without priests. Later they sent for priests and the Faith began to take root. Then the Church there underwent waves of repression resulting in great martyrdom. Although the faith survived through great heroism in the near absence of priests, it is hard to say that it flourished. Japan, however, does provide an example of priestlessness; what was left of the Faith (after early 17th-century brutal persecution wiped out the clergy) was barely recognizable by the missionaries who were allowed to return several centuries later. No priests, no Church, in the long run.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters