The Catholic Thing
HOME        ARCHIVES        IN THE NEWS        COMMENTARY        NOTABLE        DONATE
The Seven Deadly Sins, Concluded: Pride Print E-mail
By Mary Eberstadt   
Thursday, 11 March 2010

Asking someone who scribbles for a living to meditate on the Deadly Sin of Pride is like asking an alcoholic to name his poison. The danger isn’t that he’ll fail to answer. It’s rather that he might never shut up.

As the preceding columns in this series on the capital vices have shown, all of us are susceptible to all the Deadlies in different degrees, and no single occupation corners the market on any one of them. Still, I doubt that any author living or dead ever sat before a blank screen or page without knowing the sound – and sometimes the bite – of that most terrible of serpents, Pride.

The burning drive to leave a mark on one’s world, even if only in the disappearing ink of the Internet, ploughs up just the sort of soil in which Pride readily takes root. The Internet itself, especially the blogosphere, then fertilizes the results more wildly than any other medium could. To push one’s words into the public square under today’s circumstances is to know intimately just how gray is the area between promoting one’s message, worthy though it may be, and promoting oneself.

This is even true of writers for sites like The Catholic Thing and other Christian venues. Generally speaking, people who think the Church a good thing will praise our work – whereas those who hate it will find plenty to mock and scorn. Even so, getting laughed at in some of the best places doesn’t let any of us off the hook of Pride. The line between what’s good for the work and what’s good for its author remains uncomfortably blurred. Any book or other literary work today, no matter which side it’s on, is measured for success in exactly the same intrinsically self-regarding way – in Internet hits, media appearances, and that all-important totem that did not exist twenty years ago, the “Amazon number.”

And what’s true for authors is true for everyone else these days. All of us face the same problem of distinguishing what must be done to build the Kingdom from what must be done to build the Kingdom of Me. Does the diligent student work harder than anyone else in class to develop God-given talents – or because he wants to be godlike in academic prowess over others? Does the zealous volunteer labor selflessly for the good of the hospital or school – or does she work to burnish the image of herself as top charity dog?

Or consider the enormous role of “social networking,” meaning life lived online – a world in which the constant updating and promotion and image-building of oneself is not only socially acceptable, but the necessary norm. Has there ever been a bigger labyrinth than the Internet for the sin of excessive self-regard to hide?

Faced with contemporary questions like these, it helps to remember that Pride has been regarded by most Christian thinkers as the deadliest of all vices. “Pride is the first sin, the source of all other sins, and the worst sin,” says Thomas Aquinas succinctly, and many other authorities agree. In Bosch’s 1485 portrayal of Pride, a young woman preens about her new bonnet – unaware that the mirror is being held by a demon. Stealth appears common to all forms of Superbia, which is why we are not as viscerally aware of it as of Lust, or Gluttony, or Anger. But that only adds to the lethality.

Our awareness of the sin of Pride is further diminished by the fact that “obedience” as such is now regarded by many enlightened people as a questionable. We barely recognize any more that the “authority problems” of Lucifer, Eve, and Adam are cautionary tales, not portraits of role models. Many Western Catholics even go so far as to ask whether the Church has the authority to be the Church. So dulled are our modern senses to the rattle of this sin that we rarely recognize such “dissent,” as it is politely called, for what it is.

So how, given the ways of this world which are so congenial to it, can any of us hope to avoid Pride – and the rest of the serpentine pack to which we’ve grown habituated?

In his valuable book, The Seven Deadly Sins Today, which I’ve quoted elsewhere in this series, the late Henry Fairlie offers an especially helpful answer by re-phrasing the question. He boils down Pride to “an assertion of self-sufficiency – a denial of one’s need for community with others, which is in fact a form of selfishness, since it is always accompanied by a refusal of one’s obligation of community with others.”

Pride, in other words, is all about us – and as such, the only inoculation against it is to make our lives all about others instead. That is why the corresponding virtue to this deadliest vice – Charity – involves what Pride does not: other people. And ultimately, it reverses Satan’s ultimate non serviam, the refusal of dependency on and obedience to God Himself. It is only in moving outward that the incessant clamoring narcissist in all of us gets left behind. The goal for all of us, whatever we do, is to say not “I have made this because I am so clever,” but rather “I made this thanks to gifts given me to share with you.”

To correct something that Jean-Paul Sartre once got exactly backward, Hell isn’t other people. It’s one person alone in a room – with a serpent. Pride may indeed top the list of Deadlies. But in the constant motion away from oneself and towards the good of the other, we may finally find the antidote for them all.

 
Mary Eberstadt is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution, contributing editor to First Things, and a monthly columnist for thecatholicthing.org. Her new book is The Loser Letters: A Comic Tale of Life, Death, and Atheism (Ignatius Press).

(c) 2009 The Catholic Thing. All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info at thecatholicthing dot org

The Catholic Thing
is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (4)Add Comment
0
Pride
written by Joseph, March 12, 2010
Jane Austen wrote in Pride and Prejudice: Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously.... Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves, vanity to what we would have others think of us.

Well done, Mary.
0
Eternal Wisdom
written by Willie, March 12, 2010
Aside from being a deadly sin, being wrapped up in oneself is probably a good recipe for emotional disorders. Narcissistic personalities are great contributors to a psychiatrist's income. Egocentricity leads to anxiety and depressive disorders. A common solution is to unwrap oneself and get wrapped up in other people. This can be hard to do when we are so encouraged to worry about ourselves in our materialistic society. Perhaps the Scriptures and Church have an ancient Wisdom?
0
Not Stealth, Consent
written by John, March 12, 2010
"Stealth appears common to all forms of Superbia, which is why we are not as viscerally aware of it as of Lust, or Gluttony, or Anger."

Pride is not often in stealth mode, because it is over others. Lust, gluttony and anger have cultural shame; whereas all mankind consents to pride. We wish to keep our own pride intact. You are viscerally aware of pride when you want to smash the pride of the other guy, but the rest of the time you tiptoe around it. Pride is the white elephant in the room.
0
Smahing Pride in Confessi
written by me, March 12, 2010
My confession last week: God has revealed to me that my root sin is not the pride of Adam but the pride of the enemy. For in my desire to BE THE ONE to turn on the light & draw into faith those I love, I have made myself "God"! Only the Holy Spirit can convict & convert-NOT ME. Nothing I say/do changes a soul. My part is much smaller-pray & offer my life in trust that the Good Shepherd will seek out the lost, even as He has given Himself for each one of us. All His Grace-not my abilities!

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
CONTACT US FOR ADVERTISERS ABOUT US