The Catholic Thing
The Transcendent Purpose of Life Print E-mail
By James V. Schall, S. J.   
Monday, 26 July 2010

In May, Benedict XVI addressed the meeting the Italian Bishops’ Conference. The pope recalled the two issues that cause most confusion in education, and not just there. The first is the presumed complete autonomy of man; the second is skepticism about any validity in either reason or revelation. Autonomous man, the man who thinks he owes nothing to anyone but himself, does not free us but rather isolates us. We are not more ourselves with ourselves alone. The notion of person means not autonomy but openness to others: “The ‘I’ becomes itself only from the ‘thou’ and from the ‘you’. . . It is only in encounter with the ‘you’ and with the ‘we’ that the ‘I’ opens to itself.” We cannot be “educated,” let alone live, with no reference to others. We are indeed real agents, centers of our own lives. Our very being calls for more than ourselves.

Skepticism is based on two denials: the first of nature, the second of revelation. Today, nature is considered empty, with nothing to teach us, certainly nothing about ourselves. We do not find traces of intelligence in it, or if we do, we insist that they explain themselves. “Revelation,” however, “is considered either as a moment of historical development, or it is said, perhaps, there is Revelation, but it does not contain content, only motivations.” Thus, if neither nature nor revelation can indicate anything, neither can history, that recalls them, mean anything. Its only value is its own time and place. Since there is neither nature nor revelation, no abiding content comes from history.

The pope, of course, will have none of this mindlessness. Such positions, however common, are not self-evident. Both nature and human nature show clear signs of intelligent order. Revelation further clarifies and completes this already intelligible order. We can, the pope adds, recognize “the transcendent purpose of life” once it is revealed to us. We can see that this purpose is that for which each of us is created

We did not initially figure out this purpose by ourselves. But when it is revealed, it makes sense in terms of what we know: “Our answer (to what this transcendent purpose is) is the proclamation of God, the friend of man, who through Jesus became close to each one of us. The transmission of the faith is an inalienable part of the integral formation of the person because in Jesus Christ the hope of a fulfilled life is realized.” This purpose should also be known to us. We are beings that seek knowledge of what we are. This is the purpose of revelation, as if to say that we are not complete if we are given an end but no minimal indication of what it is or how to achieve it.

Benedict maintains that the economic crisis of our time is paralleled by a more serious spiritual crisis, that of not knowing our purpose. We will not really know what economics is about if we do not what we are about. In fact, as Benedict often points out, much of modern thought is a desperate, even frantic effort to propose some superior alternative to man’s transcendent purpose as given in revelation. The alternatives proposed in modern (and classical) thought are always less that what man is and what his real destiny is about. This vast difference between what God proposes for us and what we come up with as an alternative is almost ludicrous. So much so, that we must postulate some tremendous force working in our souls that blinds us to our transcendent purpose.

What is interesting about Benedict is the way he recaptures the dynamism of modernity, which proposes a self-made perfectionism. He recalls the classic Christian view that the world needs more than itself to be itself: “This is not a question of adapting the Gospel to the world but of drawing from the Gospel that everlasting newness that allows us in every age to discover the most fitting ways of spreading the Word that never dies, visualizing and serving human life.”

“Let us once more propound to the young the high and transcendent dimension of life understood as a vocation called to a consecrated life, whether it is priesthood or to marriage.” Only in this way “will each person be able to gather what is essential.”

So Benedict does not back down. Tell the world about the transcendent purpose of each of us. Tell them about the proper way to achieve it. Do not avoid the realities of life in which we are tested. But know that we need more than ourselves and our own ideas to know what we are about, which is much greater and more exalted than we could possibly have anticipated.

James V. Schall, S.J., a professor at Georgetown University, is one of the most prolific Catholic writers in America. His most recent book is
The Mind That Is Catholic.

(c) 2010 The Catholic Thing.
All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info at thecatholicthingdotorg

The Catholic Thing
is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (5)Add Comment
written by MartinK, July 27, 2010
A great reflection on a brilliant pope's thoughts. Thank you. A nice way to start my day!
written by Quaecumque Vera, July 27, 2010
Dear Professor Schall: Your submissions to this website are consistently outstanding but I found this one to be extraordinary. Would that we would all hear what it is saying and consider its meaning for our lives and our common pursuits. God Bless you for your wisdom and your courage.
Ventura County -- A small example of corrupt judges in control
written by jacob, July 27, 2010
Just go to Ventura County, CA. The people don't even have rights there..they go in front of the judge and the judge decides how much they hate the person, and how much that person deserves to suffer and then most importantly how much pension money the judge can win for the state.

The law is an absolute joke in the Ventura County Superior Court, they fine people who break it but, as they're all activists unrestrained by the law, they break it when they decide that the end of ruining a lawbreaker's life is far more important than the means, which require the righteous to be just as bad, in my opinion much worse, than the criminals they rape and violate on a daily basis.

Excellent! again!
written by Achilles, July 27, 2010
Fr. Schall sets the bar very high! Quaecumque Vera, I find myself saying this after nearly all of the good Father's essays. What a gift we have in Fr. Schall! Thank you again for drawing our attention to the higher things.

Public education has morphed into a criminal enterprise. Victor Frankel told us that hte nazi death camps were dreamed up in the universities- just one varient of single unifying theme of modern education- utopia through the will to power. The Holy Father also seems to always get it right.

Jacob, that is very disturbing.
written by Wil, July 27, 2010
Excellent! Couldn't agree more!

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


Other Articles By This Author