The Catholic Thing
Amen, sisters! Print E-mail
By Karen Walter Goodwin   
Saturday, 27 October 2012

Colleen Carroll Campbell’s My Sisters the Saints: A Spiritual Memoir, which will be released on Tuesday, expresses dissatisfaction with “pat answers offered by both secular feminists and their anti-feminist critics.”

She implicitly seeks a role in what Blessed John Paul II (in Evangelium Vitae)calls the “new feminism,” which the pope described as a culturally transforming feminism that doesn’t imitate models of male domination, but is inspired by the “true genius of women in every aspect of life and society.”

Campbell organizes her book around the inspiration of dead women who seem to channel their hard won life lessons through this gifted writer. Campbell’s venerable sisterhood includes a quaternity of “Teresas” – of Avila, Lisieux , Calcutta, and Germany (St. Teresia Benedicta of the Cross, aka Edith Stein), plus St. Faustina of Poland, and Mary of Nazareth.

Isn’t there a way for a woman of faith to be a liberated woman – a feminist? This lover of life shares Campbell’s passion to reframe the often-contentious private and public debates that follow the question.

To reach the medieval idea of the “unity of truth,” we cannot, on the one hand, ignore the dilemma of reconciling the tenets of the contemporary women’s movement – contraception, abortion rights, and suspicion of religious practice – with our own faith perspective. Nor, on the other hand, can we give short shrift to understanding the “positive intention” behind criticism of our positions.

I won’t spoil the reader’s pleasure in discovering how Ms. Campbell resolves this quandary, but other real questions are begged: Will this woman manage to escape the ravages of radical feminism? Will her parents stand by as their brilliant, high-achieving, well-formed Catholic daughter lives a curiously double life: by day, a serious undergraduate scholar, and, by night, a denizen of dissolute weekend debaucheries – at Catholic Marquette University? 

Campbell bears witness to the death throes of an American culture whose majority once aspired to virtue. She attended Marquette in the days before she might have captured the frat parties and their aftermath in the lowest forms of cinema verité – Facebook and YouTube. She did it the old-fashioned way: she kept a journal.

In My Sisters the Saints, she reveals herself to be a woman of delicate conscience, intellectual honesty, and spiritual humility. She examines sins that I daresay most priests in the confessional would consider more venial than mortal. However, she writes that in those early days of the “hookup” culture: “When it came to sex, I abided by the letter of the law I had been taught in my Catholic home – no sex outside marriage – though not its spirit.” 

The wonder of it all is that despite undergrad Colleen’s frequent visits to the loud and lusty dens of young men and their coeds – and journalist Carroll’s to the equally high-decibel environs of a White House speechwriter – she was never deafened.

Even as Ms. Carroll sought (before she became Mrs. Campbell) the temporary solace of, as Christopher West describes it, the “fast food gospel,” she could still hear the Holy Spirit, whispering. Amidst her inevitable melancholy, she still had the strength to respond to those promptings, to trust that God’s loving generosity will always shine into our personal darkness.

           Colleen Carroll Campbell

She endured the return of a sense of sin to her soul, the agony of her father’s dementia, and, with her husband, the shared sadness of an infertility diagnosis. But there were answered prayers too.

This lady knows the agony and the ecstasy of the Way of the Cross. Campbell aspires to help us discover for ourselves “the consoling truth too often forgotten in our individualistic age: that the pilgrim who seeks God never travels alone.”

Writing of her parents’ fidelity to her and her siblings’ salvation, she also reminds this mother of the power of parental prayers. We can each imitate another sister saint – Monica, mother of the reluctant Augustine – in the constancy of our prayers for our children (and spouses), no matter their progress in the journey to salvation, or our own.

Despite admitted perfectionist tendencies, Ms. Campbell manages to address her sins, although never salaciously. She bears witness to the arc of her journey – from humiliation to humility – and gives evidence of the actual graces that are at work in her life.

She invites her readers to do likewise: to take time to listen, to permit life to soften rather than harden our hearts, and to return to prayer.

One of my own saintly sisters is fourteenth-century anchoress, Julian of Norwich. What she wrote about the endurance of love is my summation of what Colleen Carroll Campbell has achieved in her own time in her evocative, deceptively plainspoken memoir:

Though we sin continually he loves us endlessly, and so gently does he show us our sin that we repent of it quietly, turning our mind to the contemplation of his mercy, clinging to his love and goodness, knowing that he is our cure, understanding that we do nothing but sin.

Lady Julian says that if there is any lover of God on this earth who is immune from falling, it was not revealed in her visions: “but this was shown: that in falling and rising again we are always held close in one love.”

Amen, sisters!

Karen Walter Goodwin is a producer with over a
dozen Broadway shows to her credit. She is founder of Fifth Avenue
Entertainment and serves on the Department of Business and Economics Advisory Board of Catholic University of America where she is adjunct professor.
The Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (7)Add Comment
written by Jack,CT, October 27, 2012
I have been a fan of Ms Cambell.
Her interviews on EWTN are fantastic,
look forward to ordering the book!
written by Charles E Flynn, October 27, 2012
Thanks for reviewing this book, which I might not have seen mentioned elsewhere.

There is a short video with the author on the page for the book.
written by Graham Combs, October 27, 2012
I too am a fan of Mrs. Campbell's interviews. Perhaps it is inconsistent to criticize the acceptance of the terms feminist and feminism since the word Catholic often tells one little about what people believe and how they behave as American citizens and as men and women, fathers and mothers. But feminism is a tiresome and offensive word. Its sins are still fresh and numerous; its devastation all around us. Working class and working poor women -- many of whom do not grow up in intact families that offer the consolations of faith and stability -- will not surivive and rise above the toxic culture that surrounds them. They are easy prey to the utopian bloviations of professional politicians, pop women's studies experts, and even misguided religious and priests offering what they cannot deliver -- purpose, meaning, family, and faith as the collaterial benefits of social activism.

What too many upper middle class experimenters don't understand is that many women don't have a wide margin for error; no one to catch them when they fall; no culture other than the thin soup of government social welfare and so called popular culture.

Sorry but I'm not interested in reconciling the realities of feminism with Catholicism or morality or Constitutionalism. I believe in forgiveness but I'm still waiting to hear an apology from the worst feminist transgressors against true religion and basic decency. What American institution haven't they blighted with this self indulgent nonsense? Does Mrs. Campbell understand what it means to live with the consequences of other people's moral pollution and intellectual dishonesty?

And what about the boys and men who endure the casual and thoughtless assault of feminist self-righteousness?
written by Achilles, October 29, 2012
I second Grahm Combs! I think trying to recover "feminizm" as a viable descriptor of womanhood might be similar to recovering "nazism" as a viable patriotism, ooops, did I just lose the arguement under Godwins eternal law? darn it!

The difficulty with recovering such a term is the fact that it is built upon the shifting sands of the ego. One can not serve two masters.
written by Donna, October 29, 2012
High praise for Goodwin's review on My Sisters, The Saints. Clearly, based on a few previous comments,no truer words were written when Goodwin notes that Campbell has a "passion to reframe the often-contentious private and public debates" in respect to the term feminism.
With Blessed John Paul II defining the "new feminism", I would say Campbell is in very good company. I pray her book goes a long way to heal individual and collective wounds.
written by Achilles, October 29, 2012
Blessed John Paul II is indeed excellent company, as long as you are indeed in his company.
written by Br. Timothy, O.P., October 30, 2012
It is so refreshing to read this! For a long time now, I've believed that the need for truly Catholic women to rally around an authentic feminism, outlined in JP2's 'Mulieris Dignitatem,' is as urgent as any other in our time. As women go, so will the world go. May the New Eve abundantly bless this endeavor!

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


Other Articles By This Author