The Catholic Thing
Lessons from Central Europe Print E-mail
By Joseph Wood   
Saturday, 15 September 2012

Editor’s Note: As Professor Wood, who has long experience in government, makes clear here, it’s no longer a stretch to see in the history of other nations parallels with the kinds of limitations on religious liberty we’re starting to see in our own country. By nature, we Americans resist such comparisons, but we’re not exempt from history or common human nature. In circumstances like these, we have to speak out before it becomes too late or at least keep alive archipelagoes of holiness, of truth. Almost every column that appears on this site also appears in French on the site of France catholique and columns regularly appear in several other languages as well. Our partners tell us that they value our work because there's rarely anything like it in their own countries.  If you value what The Catholic Thing does too, we need your support. We’re near the end of our fundraising efforts and are very close to meeting our goals. Help your poor editor to give it up and go back to the business of public Catholicism already. Please make your contribution to The Catholic Thing - and the resistance. – Robert Royal       

A few years back, I found myself meeting regularly with representatives of Central European governments and, later, often traveling to the region.  The place came to hold a fascination for reasons that were not entirely clear to me at that point.

“Central Europe” includes a great many very different peoples and places. Lithuania seems very “Catholic” in obvious ways, while Estonia does not.  The Czech Republic and Slovakia are quite different, which produced the “Velvet Divorce” after the end of the Cold War.  Poland and Croatia have deep Catholic roots that have played out in ways different than in Hungary. 

Recent political and economic developments have left the individual countries so different that many question whether it is still possible to think of them as a single region at all.

But whether someone is encountering these places for the first time or has known them for a lifetime, over and under all the differences there is an identifiable “feel” and sensibility that includes similarities in weather, architecture, historical experience, and worldview.

In my meetings with government officials and with people I came to know through Catholic connections, many of whom in the early 2000s were quite young for their posts, one common element was an appreciation of freedom that was not so obvious among their American and Western European counterparts.  These men and women still had vivid memories of communist rule.

One told me of his parents being informed that school and his university chances would go better for him if they would quit going to Mass.  Such harassment was the norm.

One reason for my fascination with the region is that some – not all – Catholics and Protestants survived, faith intact, despite the tender mercies of a powerful, modern bureaucratic-administrative state.  That state sought, with great vigor and the best available technology, to secularize society and drive religion into, at most, the home and those church buildings that were permitted to exist.  We may have something to learn from their experience.

     The Black Madonna of Częstochowa

John Hittinger of the University of St Thomas in Houston has recently described the similarities between our situation and theirs.  He cites Cardinal George’s warnings from earlier this year about the effects of the HHS mandate on provision of birth control, effectively forcing Catholic institutions to secularize or fold.  The cardinal noted that religious freedom was guaranteed in the Soviet constitution too, while the reality was very different and highly constrained.  Some Russian Orthodox Church leaders had KGB rank and perquisites.

The most prominent Catholic opponent to this Cold War reality was, of course, Cardinal Wojtyla of Poland, later Pope John Paul II.  He provided a four-point plan for the Church in those circumstances: “ (1) appeal to the rights of law and morality to fight the unjust attacks on its actions and institutions; (2) be a teacher above all, explaining the true faith and its applications to all spheres of life…; (3) use dramatic opportunities to express solidarity with those Catholics who are being attacked and those institutions being subverted; celebrate milestones and heroes of the faith in [our own] country; …4) strongly challenge and counter the ‘splitting from above and below’ [tactics of the state] and be ready to impose the doctrinal and practical discipline required to maintain the unity of faith.”

Easy to say, hard to do.  The pope won the war.  But in the battles along the way, in Poland and elsewhere, many (including clergy) were tragically co-opted by the state and collaborated in its program. 

What happened during those years that allowed Christianity to survive in Central Europe seems to have been just the most recent episode of what the late Hungarian-born Father Stanley Jaki described in his book, Archipelago Church.  He argues that the Church, in the last century and at all times when the “storms of moral destruction” blow, is really an archipelago of islands of holiness and truth rather than a continental whole.  The saints sustain these islands over the centuries, even as their locations change amidst the contingencies of history. 

Such islands have existed and continue in Western Europe as well, where secularization has proceeded apace in the last two centuries without the assistance of a communist regime.  And throughout Europe, a different but important problem has been the more friendly collaboration in secularization of a government-funded and legally instituted Church that is beholden to a large state apparatus. 

The amount of funding Catholic institutions receive from the federal government in the United States creates a similar tension between resisting the state when it overreaches in its authority, and risking the loss of the money that funds Church works.  American Catholics have traditionally supported large government social programs.  With the accrual of resources to the government to fund those programs, though, goes power as well, which can then be turned to any number of purposes, for example, the HHS mandate.

The islands of the archipelago form the “living organism” of the Church, with its ecclesial structures providing the necessary skeleton.  What was new in the last century, in Fr Jaki’s view, was the recognition of the role of the laity, which culminated in Vatican II (a council for which he also reserved considerable criticism).  To sustain the archipelago going forward, to implement Cardinal Wojtyla’s four-point plan, the laity will have to play a new role along with the hierarchy.  The role of the laity will be a major theme of the upcoming Year of Faith, beginning on October 11.

America is, we may hope, still a long way from Central Europe of the 1960s, and it would be wrongful self-victimization to compare our situation to the Christians who were facing the communist Leviathan.  But those who emerged from that region in the mid-twentieth century, with experience of what happens when the secular state undertakes to cleanse public spaces of religious influence, have much to teach us at this moment in our own history.

Joseph Wood
teaches at the Institute of World Politics in Washington.
The Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (5)Add Comment
written by Jacob R, September 15, 2012
That's what's so ironic.

There was a philosophy teacher who literally converted me to Catholicism without seeming ever to have tried. But she turned out to be a leftist Catholic and she refused to ever talk to me again simply for asking her how she could vote for Barack Obama after all the stuff about how beliefs really do matter.

Leftist Catholics are responsible for this and so are the conservatives who won't throw them out or at least keep them from destroying the church in America further. (As long as our first priority is fitting in among the secularists and not Christ we're going to continue to have big problems.)
written by Hieronymus, September 15, 2012
What the communist regimes could not achieve in Central and Eastern Europe - namely, the destruction of Christianity - the influx of Western culture is doing now with terrifying ease. Even Poland (where I was born and raised) has a major political party that supports abortion, homosexuality and the rest of this hellish litany of "individual rights". Totalitarianism is far less effective than hedonistic materialism.
written by John Hinshaw, September 15, 2012
When the time comes to honor the heroes and celebrate milestones it will be wrenching for the Church in this country. They missed the saintly men and women of our local parishes, many of whom have passed on. For 40+ years they prayed and gave witness and rescued the unborn, unknown to their pastors. If they were noticed at all it was to be called out for being "judgemental" and lectured about the seamless garment. For many years the March for Life went ignored by many diocese in this country, except for an embarassing attempt to change it to a warmer time of the calendar. Our Church is going to need to be educated about the history of what Cardinal Dolan now calls the premier civil rights issue of our times and those who brought the cause forward. The Church missed so much. It is a little disturbing (though only a little)that the Church is finally stirring now when the government is directly attacking it and not when it could have moved more energetically for others.
written by Graham Combs, September 15, 2012
Once again I find myself disagreeing with Prof. Wood. Things continue to deteriorate in this country for Catholics, for those with "unacceptable" civic values, for those of us who believe in the right to be born and that marriage is a sacrament. Once this was only a problem in the classroom, now it obtains in the workplace as well. I have encountered it in several large, well-known corporations. Those in positions of responsibility can behave without the restraints of decency and civility. Now it may well be worse in San Francisco or New York (where I lived and worked for years) or here in South East Michigan, but to say that it isn't serious is troubling. But the American Church herself remains in a weird denial. After years in publishing and law school, nothing this administration has said or done has surprised me in the least. Easily foreseeable even in the legal sense of that term. Europe has to take care of Europe. I'm worried about this country where I was born, where I live, and where my ancestors lived, worked, fought, and died since colonials times. I am so weary of this trivializaton of a true and thorough transformation that has taken place in institutional, cultural, academic, and corporate America. It's real Prof Wood, real and brutal and indecent and unconstitutional and immoral.
written by Dan, September 16, 2012
It will be heroes such as Archbishop Marcel Lefevbre who we will honor in coming decades and centuries.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters