The Catholic Thing
A Man Like No Other Print E-mail
By Anthony Esolen   
Wednesday, 13 March 2013

For the last several months I’ve been doing something that, for all I know, nobody else in the United States is doing. I’ve been learning to read Welsh by toddling through the New Testament.

That doesn’t make me unique. People do unusual things all the time; being unusual in one way or another is as common as rain.  But when you are handling the words of Jesus one by one, like riddles, even though you know what the verses will say, you see that words like usual and unusual do not describe Jesus. 

It isn’t as if Jesus stands at an extreme end of a spectrum of teachers in the ancient world. He teaches “with authority,” as the people remarked, amazed, even bewildered.  He defers to no prophet or king, not even to Moses. He does not reason people into a benignant way of life, like Buddha, nor does he embrace the traditions of a gentleman, like Confucius. 

We are to imitate Jesus, but Jesus never imitates us. He knows the heart of man, says Saint John, and he is like us in all things but sin, says Saint Paul, and he feels for our weakness, says the writer to the Hebrews, but it would sound like blasphemy to give Jesus a compliment, to call Him unusually perceptive.  It would be like saying that light is unusually illuminating, or that beauty is unusually attractive.

I’m struggling to say that there is no one in the history of the world whom Jesus resembles; although many a saint, by the grace of God, has come to resemble Jesus.  The Lord is unique.  So are the great things associated with Him.  There’s nothing in the ancient world that is like the Gospels – and that includes the foolish sham-gospels, flimsy and derivative things.

There’s nothing in the world that is like the Person or the events they describe.  The great letters of Saint Paul are unique.  The transformation of ordinary people into saints on fire to spread the Good News, unique; the kinds of people they became, unique; even the Shroud of Turin is unique – there isn’t any ancient artifact like it, and there isn’t anything close.

So I’m reading the Gospels slowly, in Welsh, and am compelled to dwell upon words that pass me by too quickly in English.  “When you give alms,” says Jesus, “do not sound a trumpet before you, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may have glory from men.  Truly I say to you, they have their reward.  But when you give alms, let not your left hand know what your right hand is doing” (Mt. 6:2-3).

If we hear those words aright, we’ll experience the shock of something wholly unexpected, but which, when expressed, strikes us, if we are steeped in the wisdom of the law and the prophets, as fulfilling the whole of the Old Testament, even though no one in the Old Testament ever says anything like it. 

           Jesus Sits by the Seashore and Preaches by James Tissot, c. 1890

And what of the ancient pagans?  Aristotle praised the virtue of magnificence, the performing of visibly great deeds, especially by means of public generosity, because he took for granted that men desire honor.  The lowliest mayor of a cowtown wants to emulate Augustus Caesar – to find Farmville in brick, and leave it, if not in marble, at least in shiny slates, and with new sidewalks; and he wants to be seen and known for it too, with a nice plaque on the village commons. 

But there is Jesus, saying, Na wyped dy law aswy pa beth a wna dy law ddehau: Let not your left hand know what your right hand is doing.  No one ever said anything like it.

So let’s pause.  Let’s not assume that it is an unusual metaphor expressing an unusual wisdom.  Let’s assume that this unique Jesus, in saying this never-said thing, has expressed it also in a unique way.  Then we will not reduce the metaphor to anything resembling a “Christian” common sense. 

We’ll not then say, “Jesus recommends that we be quiet about it, when we give alms.”  After all, there’s a way to win the approval of men quietly, so that you can double the glow of the pleasure, basking not only in the glory of your generosity, but in the knowledge that your beneficiaries cannot accuse you of pride. 

No, if the left hand is not to know what the right hand is doing, we must take care to hide our good deeds from the most fawning and flattering audience there can be – ourselves.  How is that possible?  We accuse the disciples of being slow to understand Jesus, and we’re right, they were slow.  Are we any quicker?  And did they not have cause to be slow?  How can we hide ourselves from ourselves?  How can we not know what we know?

I can’t answer my own question, but Jesus does give us a hint at where the answer must lie.  “Your Father,” He says, “who sees in secret shall reward you openly.”  We are, He has said, to be like that Father who makes His rain to fall upon the just and the unjust, in the mysteries of His wisdom and providence. 

This is the Father who sees the recesses of the heart.  He is the God who wishes to dwell in those recesses; to take away the heart of stone, even if it is gleaming marble stone, and replace it with a heart of flesh, a heart that beats with His life.

If we are to enjoy a reward, what better can it be than God Himself?  So Jesus isn’t simply warning against ostentation.  He’s inviting us into a complete surrender to the Father, so that we will not remain in our ignorant knowledge, and our alienating generosity.  It is a call to be born again.  And what is that?  Can we toddle more than a step or two beyond the beginning of that?

Anthony Esolen
is a lecturer, translator, and writer. His latest book is
Ten Ways to Destroy the Imagination of Your Child. He teaches at Providence College.
The Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

Rules for Commenting

The Catholic Thing welcomes comments, which should reflect a sense of brevity and a spirit of Christian civility, and which, as discretion indicates, we reserve the right to publish or not. And, please, do not include links to other websites; we simply haven't time to check them all.

Comments (5)Add Comment
written by Stanley Anderson, March 13, 2013
"we must take care to hide our good deeds from the most fawning and flattering audience there can be – ourselves."

Whew! Careful there -- touting that sort of thing can get one crucified and such. But, ok (brushing flustered pride down into presentable self again), as you ask, how can we? And you write, "Jesus does give us a hint at where the answer must lie. 'Your Father...' "

I love that hint, especially because it seems to fit so perfectly and yet so seemingly paradoxically with his other advice that we must become like children. I suspect that it is so that we can be like his younger self in the temple and "be about our Father's business." I am suddenly reminded of those joyful days when I would come walking around the corner of the garage into view of the front door after work and see my young toddler standing at the screen door gleefully shouting out "Dad's home!"

You end with "Can we toddle more than a step or two beyond the beginning of that?" Again, I say "Whew!" So much to consider and wonder at. Wonderful column!

And regarding the left hand not knowing what the right hand is doing, I can't help thinking of Winnie the Pooh's dilemma:
"I think it's more to the right," said Piglet nervously. "What do you think, Pooh?"

Pooh looked at his two paws. He knew that one of them was the right, and he knew that when you had decided which one of them was the right, then the other one was the left, but he never could remember how to begin.
Ironically, according to your comments we are in sort of the exact opposite condition from Pooh. We KNOW our right and left, but we are not suppose to. And we know that if we can somehow not let our left know what our right is doing, the other part will be easy, be we can never remember how to begin.

As you wrote, I also don’t know how to answer that question. All I know is that whenever my wife and I do the Joyful Mysteries in the Rosary, I always pause at the beginning of the last one, "The finding of Jesus in the Temple", and pray "May we also be found in the Temple being about our Father's business," whatever that may be.
written by Jacob, March 13, 2013
Wonderful. I particularly liked the beginning, the end and the picture.

An old teacher told me he either was a lunatic or is the Son of God.

He speaks with perfect humility, yet with an utter lack of insecurity. As you point out, he makes reference to no man.
That in itself sets him apart from every other respectable individual in history. No one who I am aware of has ever avoided coming off as a complete kook when speaking purely from his own authority, let alone founded the greatest religion in history.
written by Michael Fierro, March 13, 2013
I had a very similar experience reading the Bible in Latin, I had to pay more attention to each word and noticed things I had glossed over in English.
written by debby, March 13, 2013
this needs to be read before the Most Blessed Sacrament - one word at a time. one phrase at a time. prayerfully. over and over. i will as soon as i can get there. i hope you don't mind if i print a bunch of copies out and leave them in the Chapel.
i cannot express my gratitude today for what this has done for me. and after reading this i don't think i am "supposed" to, at least not to you.
i am not your left nor your right hand, but i could blow a trumpet before you none the less.
asking the Holy Spirit to descend even deeper into your soul and reward you, and thanking Him for His life truly present in yours.
written by Louise, March 13, 2013
I kinda get the feeling our new pope might exemplify this column.
It also occurs to me that God is being merciful to the Jesuit order...

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


Other Articles By This Author