Getting Thanksgiving Right – Redux

All of us at The Catholic Thing – Brad Miner, Karen Popp, Hannah Russo, and myself, together with our writers and technical support staff – wish all of you a very Happy and Holy Thanksgiving. Instead of the usual Thanksgiving column, which traditionally and rightly argues that we should give thanks for our blessings in America despite our ongoing sins and failures, we thought it might be of interest to republish (with just some minor editorial touch-ups) the text below, which appeared on the first Thanksgiving of TCT’s existence in 2008. It may serve as evidence of what has changed, and has not, in America during the intervening years. – Robert Royal


In The Good Shepherd, Robert DeNiro’s film about how the CIA was founded through old, mostly WASP networks at Yale, Matt Damon (playing a CIA operative) visits Joe Pesci (playing a Mafia figure) in a Miami café. They work out an agreement that the mob will help the U.S. government take out Cuban Communist dictator Fidel Castro. Then Pesci – curious about the stiff WASP sitting in front of him – leans across the table:

“Lemme ask you a question. Italians, we got the Church, we got family. The Irish, they have their homeland. The Jews, they have their tradition. Even the n*****s got their music. What do you people have?”

(Damon): “The United States of America. The rest of you are just visiting.”

Things are no longer thus for ethnic Americans, partly because there are so many of them in the CIA, FBI, and the government generally that, it would be difficult for America to function without them. But there is still a warning here. For a large swath of us now, some formerly on the margins, America has become our religion.

Today is the day we traditionally give thanks for the many blessings God has showered on the United States and its people. And it’s entirely fitting because we live in one of the greatest nations in human history, despite great problems: from slavery in the earliest colonies to the current financial crisis. As we celebrate, however, it’s also a good thing to remind ourselves that the first Thanksgiving was not organized to thank God for the Pilgrims’ per capita income, the might of their military forces, tolerance of others, or the multicultural society they had formed with the Indians. The Pilgrims were grateful just to have survived and been allowed by God to continue their search for real liberty and holiness. That is always the true spiritual note of gratitude.

In recent years, Thanksgiving has sometimes gotten lost in extreme politicization between the saccharine sentimentalism of American boosters and the bitter radicalism of America’s critics. Both sides have made America into a kind of secular religion, for good or bad, praise or blame, perfection or perdition. For example, David Gerlernter, the victim of a terrorist bombing at Yale, produced a remarkable book last year [2007], Americanism: the Fourth Great Western Religion, which, though marred by his exaggerated main thesis, combines great insights about the spiritual and moral values that our country has added to its Jewish and Christian heritage – and to the world.


A temptation lurks here, however, that has recurred historically. If you don’t believe – and strongly at that – in a God Who transcends and needs to save the world, you will be strongly tempted to believe in some lesser god-substitute. A nation is a perpetually plausible alternative because it participates in several divine attributes. Authority over other men and, at times, power over life and death, are not just another set of practical arrangements within a commercial republic. The mysterious ways that a regime and its laws and lands, peoples and history, grow into a living human society, though by no means divine, reflect something at work in history that is beyond any of us individually. For that very reason, if Christianity does not remain faithful to itself, it can quickly be absorbed into a kind of divinized politics. This is true whether you believe in Americanism as a “religion” or in some anti-American liberation theology.

Among the many things it is good for a Catholic to remember today, because they anchor us in a reality outside the quite proper human fellowship we will be celebrating, is the Eucharist, which means, literally in Greek, giving thanks. St. Paul says, “give thanks (eucharisteite) always” (1 Thess 5:13) and reports that Jesus Himself even “on the night he was betrayed” gave thanks. (1 Corinthians 11:23). Catholics can bring to the American mix precisely this sense of a gratitude that extends beyond the good things of life as most people understand what’s “good,” to something much greater, even in the midst of immediate evils, something that exists on an entirely different plane than the greatest regimes, however much we are grateful for them in our human way.

Even the modern philosophers have caught echoes of this truth. Some years ago I was reading Martin Heidegger, the existentialist philosopher most used by postmodern professors to terrorize university students. In his later, more mystical period, Heidegger often cited the old German Pietist saying, Denken is Danken, “To think is to thank.” Whenever we take the trouble to know the real truth, we render a kind of gratitude to reality. And the truth is that we are fragile creatures in a vast universe, but destined for eternity. As Chesterton put it: “It is the root of all religion that a man knows he is nothing in order to thank God that he is something.”

I love Thanksgiving Day and have no doubt schoolchildren thousands of years from now will learn in that obscure and dead language, American English, all about our odd habits such as turkeys (including the one pardoned every year by the president), cranberry sauce, and pro football – in much the same way that we study the social ways of ancient Greece, Rome, and China. But I also hope that their teachers will be better than ours in making clearer the whole range of what it is that America celebrates today and Who it is that Thanksgiving is meant to thank.


*Image: Thanksgiving by Salvatore Lascari, 20th century [Smithsonian American Art Museum, Washington, D.C.]

You may also enjoy:

Brad Miner’s Thanks . . . Again

Fr. Romano Guardini’s The Virtue of Gratitude

Robert Royal is editor-in-chief of The Catholic Thing and president of the Faith & Reason Institute in Washington, D.C. His most recent books are Columbus and the Crisis of the West and A Deeper Vision: The Catholic Intellectual Tradition in the Twentieth Century.